For years, motorcycle enthusiasts have debated the merits of loud exhaust pipes, with many riders claiming that “loud pipes save lives.”
This controversial stance has pitted riders against residents and even other motorcyclists.
The argument for loud pipes stems from the belief that increased noise makes motorcycles more noticeable to other drivers (and wildlife), potentially preventing accidents. Some riders swear by their personal experiences, claiming that car drivers have reacted to their loud exhausts, avoiding potential collisions.
However, the case against loud pipes is compelling. The 1981 Hurt Report, a seminal study on motorcycle safety, found no evidence that motorcycles with modified exhausts were less likely to be involved in crashes.
In fact, the report suggested a slight over representation of modified exhausts in accident data.
Another study released in 2020 by the Association for the Development of Motorcycling in Romania found the quote “Loud pipes save lives” to be a myth.
The study included several motorcycle brands, microphones, and recording equipment.
The results determined that by the time a driver in a modern car can hear the loud pipes on a motorcycle, it would not give them enough time to react to avoid hitting a motorcyclist. Visibility is more important than loud bikes.
Other key findings include:
- A noisy exhaust increases the noise produced behind the motorcycle but modifies to a small extent the noise transmitted to the car in front.
- A motorcycle is not heard in a moving car if it is at a distance greater than 50 feet, regardless of how modified the exhaust is and regardless of the background noise in the cabin.
- At distances of 33 feet from the car, a motorcycle (with a noise level produced above legal limits) can be heard, but the sound is in a low frequency range where the sound is difficult for the human ear to identify and difficult to position in space.
- To be heard in a car 50 feet away, a motorcycle would have to produce a sound level at the exhaust pipe of over 135dB(A), a condition impossible to meet in reality.
One of the primary scientific arguments against the effectiveness of loud pipes is the Doppler Effect. This phenomenon means that the majority of the exhaust noise is directed behind and to the sides of the motorcycle, not in front where most accidents occur.
By the time a driver ahead hears the motorcycle, it may already be too late to react.
Moreover, prolonged exposure to loud noise can lead to hearing loss and reduced concentration for riders, potentially increasing the risk of accidents. Many experienced riders opt for quieter helmets or wear earplugs to combat noise fatigue.
Instead of relying on questionable noise tactics, motorcyclists should focus on proven safety measures. Proper protective gear, including helmets and reflective clothing, along with defensive riding techniques, are far more effective in preventing accidents.
Visibility enhancements such as bright colors and always-on headlights have been recognized as aids to conspicuity in major safety studies.
The debate around loud pipes also raises legal and social considerations. Many communities have noise regulations that riders with modified exhausts may violate. This can lead to strained relationships with neighbors and negative public perception of motorcyclists as a whole.
It’s crucial to consider the role of driver awareness in motorcycle safety. Educating all motorists about sharing the road responsibly and being vigilant for motorcycles is essential. However, relying on loud pipes to compensate for lack of awareness is not a sustainable solution.
As technology advances, modern motorcycles are incorporating more safety features. The rise of electric motorcycles may even render the loud pipes debate obsolete in the future. These developments highlight the need for a comprehensive approach to motorcycle safety that goes beyond noise levels.
In conclusion, while the debate over loud pipes continues, the evidence suggests that they are not a reliable safety measure. Instead, they may create a false sense of security for riders while potentially increasing risks due to noise fatigue.
A more balanced approach to motorcycle safety, focusing on visibility, rider skills, and motorist education, is likely to be more effective in saving lives without the negative community impact of excessive noise.
The full Romanian study can be found here.
Meet the Daredevils That Push the Boundaries of Motorcycle Stunts
These bikes may not have loud pipes, but they are filled with action packed excitement. These skilled motorcyclists push all boundaries and defy gravity with amazing motorcycle stunts.
Harley Davidson’s Wrecking Crew Were Original Motorcycle Rebels
It was the the early 1900s when Harley recruited fearless riders for their “Wrecking Crew” riding team. That team would solidify their spot in the racing world.
This article was originally published on greaseculture.com.
